Aisle vs. Window: The Power of Choice

Over on the Hunch blog, the results of 32,000 survey responses regarding peoples preferences for window or aisle seats on flights have been dissected. From a seemingly simple question, Hunch was able to draw conclusions about the socio-economic factors that come into play when determining preference with regards airplane seating – to summarize the findings, Hunch tells us that:

  • Window choosers are more likely to be younger, female, shorter, and more casual than their aisle compatriots. They’re also more likely to be into nature (makes sense) and enjoy camping. In general, though, they are not particularly well-traveled — yet — and they enjoy the comforts of home. They admit that they can be ‘bed hogs’, which is why you might find them encroaching on your space with their carry-ons or reading material. They are also less plugged in (technically) than the aisle types, although they enjoy reading and are more likely to visit a real brick and mortar bookstore. (Remember those?)
  • Aisle choosers mean business. They are more likely to be older, male, taller, more educated, dressed up, and with higher incomes than window gazers. They are likely to have an AMEX card, a valid passport, and premier status on at least one airline. They likely subscribe to several magazines and are more likely to stick to one side of the bed at night (but perhaps only because someone else is also more likely to be on the other side).

The article is an interesting read, and worth five minutes of your time for entertainment value. But for those who spend their time wondering about ways to generate the highest levels of customer satisfaction, there are some interesting insights we can gain from the post.

First and foremost is that people want choice. Choice to chose the approach that best suits them and choice to change solutions based on situations.We’ve written in the past about some people preference for automated call centers versus speaking to a real person. We’ve looked at automatic voice recognition versus a “push this number for…” approach.

Swinging back to the “aisle vs. window” question – I’m a perfect example of a desire for choice. When travelling to new locales I’ll generally choose a window seat to have a bit of a look at the scenery. For short domestic flights it’s aisle every time. For long hauls, it’s aisle for exit row or window otherwise – you’ll see that I have several different situations that determine my preference, add to this the fact that I’m a random sort of a guy who sometimes mixes things up for fun, and you can see that any prescriptive approach just simply won’t work.

Customer service situations are the same. Think of any setting – hospitality, retail, service-based – it’s a safe bet that your preference for how service is delivered; be it personalized or automatic, on-line or off, leisurely or short and sweet, depends much on the situation you’re in and the million little contextual details behind that situation.

So for those whose work revolves around providing for interactions with customers, don’t lose sight of the fact that everyone is different, engineer choice into your processes and make sure you can meet everyone’s needs – window seaters, aisle seaters and everyone in-between.

Illustration courtesy of Hunch Blog.

  • http://cloudofdata.com Paul Miller

    aisle for short haul – eh? What's the rationale behind that one Ben?

    Personally, I'll always choose window for short haul and aisle for long haul… unless I'm travelling in Biz. Then it's window every time.

    • http://www.joshchandlerva.com Josh Chandler

      Paul,

      I would choose window because it then means I have something else to do if I don't want to focus on work!

  • Stuart Fawcett

    Window for scenery/sleeping on longer flights, Isle & front for quick release on regular business flights. But let me choose each time, don't offer me the middle, we all wan't to carve out our own little area of individuality from amongst the multitude of similar offerings, or at the very least CHOOSE not to have the little stool at the back as I'm better than that. if i choose then i'll complain less even if it is really just Hobson's choice.

  • Justin

    Isn't the question whether you want to 'walk over' or be 'walked over' when someone needs the toilet? Long Haul I try to have the window seat to be out of the way. Although on the last flight to San Francisco I chose the aisle seat so perhaps that boxes me in the "Means business" category which is the mindset I was in. Interesting post Ben. Cheers